Few legal disputes are as personal and emotional as challenging a will. Contesting a will in Ontario can affect family relationships, financial legacies, and the administration of an estate. Understanding when and how a will can be challenged helps set realistic expectations for executors, beneficiaries, and those considering a challenge.
Grounds for Contesting a Will in Ontario
Ontario courts start with the presumption that a validly signed will reflects the true intentions of the deceased. To succeed in a challenge, one of the following grounds must be proven:
-
Lack of testamentary capacity – The testator did not understand what they were signing, the nature of their assets, or the claims of those who might expect to benefit.
-
Undue influence – The testator was pressured or coerced into making the will, and it does not reflect their independent intentions.
-
Improper execution – The will was not signed and witnessed in accordance with Ontario’s legal requirements.
-
Fraud or forgery – The document is not authentic, or the testator was misled into signing it.
-
Suspicious circumstances – Even if the will appears valid, unusual circumstances may lead the court to examine whether the will truly reflects the testator’s wishes.
Who Can Contest a Will?
Not everyone has the right to challenge a will. In Ontario, the right generally belongs to those with a financial interest in the estate, such as:
-
Beneficiaries named in the contested will
-
Beneficiaries under a prior will
-
Individuals who would inherit if no will exists, such as spouses, children, or other close relatives
The Process of Contesting a Will
-
Initial review – A lawyer examines the will, surrounding circumstances, and supporting documents to assess the strength of the case.
-
Filing a Notice of Objection – This document formally prevents the court from granting probate until the issues are resolved.
-
Evidence gathering – Medical records, witness testimony, drafting lawyer notes, and other documents are collected to support or defend the will.
-
Court proceedings – The dispute may be resolved through motions, examinations, mediation, or a full trial.
-
Resolution – The court either upholds the will, sets it aside in whole or part, or accepts a prior valid will.
Risks and Considerations
Challenging a will is not straightforward. Parties should carefully weigh:
-
Costs – Estate litigation can be expensive, and courts may order the losing party to pay.
-
Time – These disputes can take months or years to resolve, delaying estate administration.
-
Emotional toll – Will challenges often deepen family conflicts and strain relationships.
-
Uncertain outcome – Even with strong evidence, courts may decide against the challenger.
Alternatives to Litigation
Not every concern requires a court battle. Mediation and negotiation can help parties reach a compromise, preserve family relationships, and reduce costs. In some cases, addressing issues through legal advice early can prevent a challenge from escalating.
How Kimel Law Group Can Help
At Kimel Law Group, we focus exclusively on estate litigation and estate administration in Ontario. Whether you are considering contesting a will or defending against a challenge, our team provides clear advice, careful preparation, and strong representation. We guide clients through every stage of the process, balancing the legal, financial, and personal stakes involved.
Contact us today to discuss your situation and learn how we can help you navigate the complexities of contesting a will in Ontario.